Alberta Fact Check: Alberta nurse’s union claims independence would end pensions and public health care, among other things
The evidence suggests Alberta’s health care funding scenario would be just fine if the province became independent.
In a press release replete with hyperbolic statements about the consequences of Alberta independence, the Alberta Nurse’s Union made its stance on the upcoming referendum clear. They haven’t let themselves be bound by the truth.
The first claim is that independence would lead to the end of health care funding from the federal government and the conditions of the Canada Health Act. This is all true. But they neglect to mention that the funding coming from the federal government came from Albertan taxpayers in the first place.
It’s not money from some hidden cache of health dollars that the federal government mines and hands to Albertans. The original Canada Health Act regulations called for the federal government to fund 50 percent of provincial health costs. It only covers about 20 percent of Alberta’s.
With the massive disparity between outgoing federal tax dollars and what the federal government transfers back, Alberta’s health care funding scenario would be just fine.
In leaving the constraints of the federal legislation governing health care, Alberta could embrace European and Asian models that offer universal coverage for citizens and have superior outcomes when compared to Canada’s failing system.
In Canada, the only remedy for any health care ailments is to prescribe more money to it, which only feeds the unions further, while patients pass away awaiting care. Independence offers an opportunity for much-needed reform.
The union claims that independence would put pensions at risk.
The Canada Pension Plan is transferable. A person may reside in any country they choose; they are still entitled to collect from the plan they contributed to. In the unlikely scenario where the Canadian government felt it could steal the pension entitlements from Albertans, the balance could be reduced from any debt Alberta would consider assuming upon independence.
The CPP benefits owed to Albertans, paltry as they are, are perfectly safe. The nurse’s union pensions are only at risk from the management of the union entrusted with the principle. That’s between the nurses and their union representatives.
The release claims an independent Alberta would reduce or eliminate labour protections. There has been no claim or indication that any independence leaders or citizens in general are interested in eliminating collective bargaining rights or safety regulations.
The union asserts that labour mobility will be impacted by independence. That’s rich considering the current interprovincial barriers for health care workers are often more difficult to navigate than international ones. There is plenty of demand for health care workers in all jurisdictions within and outside of Canada. Mobility won’t be an issue.
The release finishes by saying independence threatens treaty rights. That realm is completely outside of the union's wheelhouse, and it shows with their clear lack of knowledge on the issue. No treaties are threatened by independence today any more than they were when Trudeau Sr. repatriated the constitution.
Governments can change while treaties remain. Independence will cover 98.7 percent of the province, which was forever ceded in the treaties, while Indigenous bands can maintain the 1.3 percent, which is reserve land.
The status quo serves union leaders well. Particularly in fields with mandated monopolies such as health care. Unfortunately, it serves citizens terribly as access to health care in Canada has become a chronic problem, making it sink in all measures of health care performance internationally.
Unfortunately, health care unions are more concerned with maintaining a failing system for their own benefit rather than seeking reforms which may help ailing and dying citizens awaiting care. Independence offers a way to break free from the current health care system which is in a spiral to the bottom.
Cory Morgan
Cory Morgan is an Alberta-based columnist, political commentator, and longtime advocate for Western Canadian independence. He is the author of the recently updated book The Sovereigntist’s Handbook, a grassroots guide for independence supporters and political activists.
http://sovereigntistshandbook.com/
COMMENTS
-
Matthew Beatty commented 2026-07-07 08:48:52 -0400Let’s not be too harsh on unions, nurses union is vital and of significance in its proportion to Alberta.
In a nursing world it’s a harsh reality of emotional roller coaster, firstly dealing with daily obligations and then reality of being a caregiver. That alone goes unremarkable acknowledged ,in its own reality. I’m sure being a front line caregiver has , many moments of tears and those of joy, it’s an awkward situation, that you don’t live it, you may never know , that experience.
They are a collective body of significance and of value, and voting power. Which rightly so , they need to speak up when needed. We should listen in good faith.
Rightfully, concerns of pension should be raised and consideration given to that, once again in good faith.
Independents of Alberta , will address those issues, I’m sure it may even advance the situation for even better opportunities for them.
Additionally, a the union should see opportunity rather than the other, for its members. I can’t see a better time for both sides to examine the total system , making it better for both sides.
So, let’s hear, what the issue are and negotiate a better system for all Albertans and their healthcare system so things can improve and that’s a good thing. -
Bruce Atchison commented 2026-07-06 19:51:25 -0400Unions suck. They shouldn’t be allowed to be politically active. I wish Danielle Smith would put forth legislation to that effect. Unions are supposed to be dealing ONLY with capital, not politicians.
