Fact Check: Alberta’s push for opt-out rights is neither impossible nor unprecedented
So-called 'experts' are applauding Quebec's assertion of provincial rights while decrying Alberta’s efforts to do the same thing.

A CTV News piece, “Can Alberta opt out of federal programs? ‘Impossible,’ experts say,” presents a skeptical view of Question 8 on Alberta’s upcoming referendum. The question asks whether Albertans support their government working with other willing provinces to amend the Constitution so that provinces can opt out of federal programs in areas of provincial jurisdiction (health care, education, social services) without losing the associated funding for their own programs.
The experts sought out by CTV were avowed federalists Jared Wesley and Timothy van den Brink, who contended that trying to amend the constitution was impossible and the effort in itself would likely open a Pandora’s Box once provinces begin lobbying for changes.
These contentions understate both historical precedent and the structural problem Alberta is highlighting. The opting out could come without constitutional changes as well.
The most direct counter to claims of impossibility is Quebec’s experience. In the 1960s, under arrangements offered by the federal government, Quebec opted out of several shared-cost programs in areas of provincial jurisdiction including hospital insurance, social welfare programs, and youth allowances. In return, it received tax-point abatements so it could fund its own equivalent programs. This produced the Quebec Abatement, which continues today.
Quebec also operates its own public pension plan rather than the Canada Pension Plan and has a distinct immigration settlement agreement under which it receives compensation for delivering integration services. These arrangements were political bargains, not constitutional rights available to every province as of right. But they demonstrate that opting out of federal involvement in provincial fields while retaining fiscal capacity is feasible and has been done for decades. Alberta’s proposal is essentially an attempt to generalize and constitutionalize a principle that has already been applied to one province.
As per usual though, “experts” in Canada applaud Quebec’s assertion of provincial rights while decrying Alberta’s efforts to do the same thing.
Through a constitutional amendment clarifying provincial roles, the endless negotiations and battles between the federal and provincial governments could be eased. Securing a constitutional amendment is difficult. It is not, however, a formal impossibility, and describing it as such in the context of a referendum is rhetorical rather than analytical. A clear yes vote in Alberta would not compel other provinces to agree, but it would put the issue on the agenda and test whether other provinces share similar frustrations with federal spending in their fields. Alberta’s referendum could get the ball rolling nationally.
If indeed constitutional change is impossible as per Wesley and van den Brink’s contentions, they are only making the case for Albertans to choose Option 2 on Question 10 in the list of referenda questions presented to them. Any other attempts at reform are apparently futile.
Cory Morgan
Cory Morgan is an Alberta-based columnist, political commentator, and longtime advocate for Western Canadian independence. He is the author of the recently updated book The Sovereigntist’s Handbook, a grassroots guide for independence supporters and political activists.
http://sovereigntistshandbook.com/