Ontario Superior Court issues interim injunction against Toronto hospital network's vaccine mandate

This is purportedly the first time that a vaccine mandate in Ontario has been impeded by the courts.

Ontario Superior Court issues interim injunction against Toronto hospital network's vaccine mandate
Remove Ads

The Ontario Superior Court has issued an interim injunction against the University Health Network's attempts to terminate a group of unvaccinated employees, the Toronto Sun reports.

The University Health Network (UHN) encompasses the Toronto General and Toronto Western hospitals, the Princess Margaret Cancer Centre, the Toronto Rehabilitation Institute and The Michener Institute of Education.

Six UHN employees brought forward an urgent motion to the court on Friday afternoon, which was the deadline UHN had set to terminate those who had not yet taken the COVID-19 vaccine.

"The harm raised by the applicants is potentially serious and cannot be undone," wrote Ontario Superior Court Justice Sean Dunphy, in a decision issued Friday. "It is alleged that some or all of them may be compelled to take the vaccine against their will because they cannot in their personal and family circumstances take the risk of being left destitute by the policy they are seeking to challenge."

This is purportedly the first time that a vaccine mandate in Ontario has been impeded by the courts.

The interim injunction does not apply to all of the "approximately 180 … [UHN] employees refusing the vaccine," but rather just to the six plaintiffs and 19 others who were in the process of joining the legal action at the time the motion was launched. It is also not a permanent injunction, but rather pauses the effects of the mandate for one week until the court can reconvene on Thursday. The court will then determine whether or not the court even has jurisdiction over the matter, as UHN argues it is a matter of collective bargaining over which the court does not have a say.

Justice Dunphy emphasized that the issuing of the injunction should not be mistaken for a judgment on the actual mandate, stating that "there may be merit to both positions" and that the Ontario judge would "need time to be better briefed."

One lawyer who has clients planning to add their names to the list of plaintiffs said there may be broader implications that stem from this injunction.

"While the Court has only issued an interim injunction based on the specific facts of this case, it will give pause to other employers throughout Ontario which have adopted policies to terminate employees who are not vaccinated," wrote Ryan O’Connor, a partner at Zayouna Law Firm, in an email to the Toronto Sun. "It may also cause employers to pay greater attention to requests for accommodations or exemptions under workplace vaccination policies."

In a statement to the Toronto Sun on the matter, UHN wrote: "A small number of individuals sought and received an interim injunction until later this week. UHN has no comment on this matter as it is before the court."

Rebel News has launched its own series of legal challenges against the vaccine mandates, in partnership with the registered Canadian civil liberties charity The Democracy Fund. You can read more about our active legal cases here.

We are taking on 20 strategic cases across Canada to fight back against the vaccine passport mandates. If you yourself are being forced to take a vaccine against your will, or are being punished if you won’t, you can fill out a confidential form, telling us who you are, who is trying to force you to take a vaccine, and what they’re saying to you. (The actual wording of their threat is important.) Our constitutional litigators will review your information and if we can help you, we will — free of charge.

Do you oppose the use of vaccine passports in Canada? Go to FightVaccinePassports.com to sign our petition, share with us your forced vaccination story and donate to help fund our legal battles against vaccine passports across Canada.

Remove Ads
Remove Ads

  • By Ezra Levant

Fight Vaccine Passports

A new civil liberties project — fighting against forced vaccines!

Learn More

Don't Get Censored

Big Tech is censoring us. Sign up so we can always stay in touch.

Remove Ads