Victory! Defamed music teacher takes on Toronto’s woke school board in court
Violet Shearer's career took a bizarre twist in May 2016 when she led a performance of elementary students in a song entitled, Land of the Silver Birch.
The story of retired Toronto music teacher Violet Shearer is equal parts baffling and egregious. The good news: her saga comes with a happy ending.
Here’s the skinny: Violet worked for the Toronto District School Board for almost 30 years. But her career took a bizarre twist in May 2016 when she led a performance of elementary students in a song entitled, Land of the Silver Birch.
Alas, a few parents in attendance complained to the school administration regarding the performance. They alleged that the song was “inappropriate and racist.”
And that led to an email from the administration to the entire school community, branding the performance as “inappropriate and racist”, and by extension, Violet was racist.
Yet, the questions arises: what exactly makes Land of the Silver Birch racist?
Incredibly, to this day, that question remains unanswered. Apparently, some condemn the song for “romanticizing Indigenous culture.” But how does this qualify as racism? Indeed, Violet says that even the school administrators could not explain in tangible terms how the song, that dates back more than a century, is racist. But they bent the knee to a couple of parents who deemed it to be racist nevertheless.
But Violet fought back. She commenced a defamation lawsuit against the TDSB in order to clear her reputation. And some nine years later, we have closure. Spoiler alert: Violet was victorious.
The victory is bittersweet. Violet, who self-represented, went through enormous stress. But she had friends who helped out. And get this: she reviewed all the defamation cases involving Rebel News’s Ezra Levant to mount her challenge and make her case. And even though Violet was going up against the TDSB legal eagles, she prevailed.
Violet was seeking damages of $1 million, although she cannot say what the precise settlement amounted to.
However, part of the settlement involved a public apology to Violet from the TDSB. And she was not compelled to sign a non-disclosure agreement regarding the nitty-gritty details of the litigation, so she is free to speak about her case.
She was also recently announced as the recipient of the 2025 Richard Bilkszto Award, which represents freedom of expression.
And while Violet has moved on from teaching music, she is now training to become a paralegal. Her focus is education law, and Violet says the goal is to represent other teachers who are unfairly maligned by their woke and weak school administrators and school board educrats.
We wish her well.

David Menzies
Mission Specialist
David “The Menzoid” Menzies is the Rebel News "Mission Specialist." The Menzoid is equal parts outrageous and irreverent as he dares to ask the type of questions those in the Media Party would rather not ponder.

COMMENTS
-
Paul Taalman commented 2025-05-06 22:03:25 -0400I am 65 years old. Born and raised in Ontario. Went to a Catholic school in Richmond Hill for my elementary school education. Somewhere between approximately 55 and 60 years ago, I along with other kids in my class learned the song Song of the Silver Birch. When a portion of it played on this video, I recognized it right away and began to sing along. I never in my time singing this song thought that it was anything more than a tribute to Canada’s Indian past. At the time, I pictured myself in a birch bark canoe dipping my silver paddle into Ontario’s pristine waters. When I was a kid, we may have even sung it as we paddled along in our neighbour’s canoe at our cottage. We had a ski boat, our neighbours had a canoe that they allowed us to use. It takes a pretty shallow and demented/racist mind to call this song racist. I see it as a tribute to our aboriginal past. I would like to know who these people are that complained. I can just imagine who they are – white, female, liberal, university educated (with not an ounce of common sense), progressive Libtards. By the way, when I sing our national anthem, I also sing: “In all thy sons command.” As did everyone at Pierre Poilievre’s rally in Oshawa back in April. I’m not changing the words of my nation’s song because ONE FAG didn’t like the words – in the anthem’s case; “In all thy sons command” is INCLUSIVE. Those who are offended need to get over themselves. I don’t like Marx Con Carney as our Prime Minister. How come no one allows ME to tell the 41 million other Canadians that he needs to be “changed.”
-
Ruth Bard commented 2025-05-06 16:53:40 -0400Good for her!! I remember that song from my days as a classroom music teacher, waaaaay back. A bit sappy, maybe, but racist? Nah.
-
Crude Sausage commented 2025-05-06 11:04:56 -0400Congratulations to her. I think that at this point, everyone’s response to anyone who screams “racism” is to just ignore them. We’re all fatigued to the point where we don’t even care if something discriminates in any way anymore.