BECOME A MEMBER

Monthly Annual

Rebel News +

Our most popular subscription

• View RebelNews.com without ads
• Includes 1 free week of RebelNews+
• Access all RebelNews+ shows
• Access Comments and RN+ features

$8

Per month CAD

Join RebelNews+ Now

Producers Club

Our top supporters

• View RebelNews.com without ads
• Includes 1 free week of RebelNews+
• Access all RebelNews+ shows
• Access Comments and RN+ features
• Invites to producers club only events
• Special discount at RebelNewsStore.com
• Free gifts for members, like signed books

$22

Per month CAD

Join Producers Club Now

---

Article by Rebel News staff

Go Ad Free

Tonight, on The Ezra Levant Show, a feature interview with David Knight Legg about the disastrous scuppering of the free trade negotiations. 

Something doesn't add up about the collapse of the Canada-U.S. trade talks, and Ezra went looking for an answer from someone who has actually sat at that table before. David Knight Legg is the former senior advisor to Jason Kenney when he was premier of Alberta. His job in that role was to win back the foreign investors who had fled the province during the NDP years.

David now works the Canada-U.S. file from both sides of the border, and he told Ezra that the official story of why the deal fell apart doesn't survive contact with what Washington is actually saying.

"In the last 48 hours you have two completely different perspectives on what happened," David said, contrasting the blunt accounts coming from U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer and Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent with the far vaguer explanation Canadians got from Prime Minister Mark Carney.

Carney told Canadians the deal collapsed because Washington demanded a "veto" over who Canada does business with — framing it as an attack on Canadian sovereignty. But Ezra pointed out that provision already exists, buried in the very free trade agreement Canada signed. It lets any of the three CUSMA partners walk away on six months' notice if one of them cuts a deal with a non-market economy like China. It's not new, and as Ezra noted, it actually protects Canada more than it protects the Americans.

Then there's Carney's other explanation — that the talks broke down over an attack on French language and Quebec culture. Ezra played a clip of Ambassador Greer being asked directly about it.

A lot of funny+fake stories going around. Some of them appear to be coming from our side.

When is the federal govt going to release the notes that will inform Canadians whether it made sense to walk away or not? https://t.co/Ki0ElrTIIA

— David Knight Legg (@KnightLegg) August 24, 2026

Greer's answer was blunt: Washington has no problem with French, or with Quebec culture. What it objects to is Ottawa forcing American streaming companies like Netflix to hand over a percentage of their earnings to Canadian and Quebec content producers — a policy the Americans call a discriminatory tax, full stop.

"Mark Carney translated that into a 'they're-attacking-our-French-fact'," Ezra said. "I think Carney weaponized everything, spun it almost beyond recognition."

Meanwhile, David noted, the countries that got deals done with Washington didn't dither. The U.K. is done. Japan is done. Mexico, Taiwan, Indonesia and Malaysia are all done. Canada has been at this for more than 600 days.

David didn't spare Ontario's Doug Ford or Manitoba's Wab Kinew — whose province, he said, has been "completely falling apart" economically, contributing to the "economic weakness" that has made negotiating with the Americans even more difficult. 

Ford, David said, has been threatening to cut off electricity, oil and potash to the Americans, despite the fact that the oil comes from Alberta and the potash from Saskatchewan — resources that aren't his to threaten with. Worse, David said Ford is now reportedly trying to recruit Alberta Premier Danielle Smith to join him in shutting down Alberta's oil industry as a show of solidarity.

"I hope that she stays far away from this," David said, contrasting Ford and Kinew's combative posture with the "businesslike" approach Smith and Saskatchewan's Scott Moe took in Washington.

With more than 100,000 Canadian jobs on the line and five straight quarters of declining business investment, David said Carney's decision to vacation in Tuscany just before the deal collapsed was simply indefensible.

"It was a terrible decision," he said. "I don't know what his advisers were thinking."

But David noted that the deeper tragedy is that Canada has no positive vision to counter any of this. He pointed to Alberta's revival of the Keystone XL pipeline project after Obama-era officials killed it, and to Alberta's corporate tax cut from 12 to eight per cent — both signs, he said, of what a serious economic strategy looks like. Nationally, he pointed to Canada's worst-in-the-OECD productivity decline and a brain drain that has sent 517 Canadian-founded startups worth $4.4 trillion in value south of the border.

"What is the plan for Canada?" David asked. "Where's the positive economic, political and military vision for this country to be great in the world?"

As it stands, he said, Ottawa is "dithering" over a grievance contest with Washington while the jobs of ordinary Canadians hang in the balance — and unlike the politicians doing the grandstanding, those workers are the ones who will actually pay the price.

---

GUEST: Longform interview with energy, security, and economic development advisor David Knight Legg.