Blue Jays outfielder Anthony Santander apologizes for posts about Islam as the controversy enters its 12th day

Santander's posts about Islam after the U.S. midterm elections were branded Islamophobic across Toronto media. Guest host David Menzies looks at the fallout and at why Rogers' own past actions call the company's response so far into question.

BECOME A MEMBER

rn-plus

Rebel News +

Our most popular subscription
  • View RebelNews.com without ads
  • Cancel anytime
  • Access all RebelNews+ shows
  • Access Comments and RN+ features

$8

Per month CAD

Producers Club

Our top supporters
  • View RebelNews.com without ads
  • Cancel anytime
  • Access all RebelNews+ shows
  • Access Comments and RN+ features
  • Invites to producers club only events
  • Special discount at RebelNewsStore.com
  • Free gifts for members, like signed books

$22

Per month CAD


Article by Rebel News staff.

Tonight on The Ezra Levant Show: Rogers, the owner of the Toronto Blue Jays, wants contrition from an outfielder over his social-media posts, yet until recently it employed a senior system analyst whose own posts declared that "everyone is sick of Jews like you." Rebel News' David Menzies guest hosts, and Ezra Levant joins the program with a segment from Taiwan.

Anthony Santander posted about the results of the U.S. midterm elections earlier this month. The story broke on Nov. 4. On Nov. 16, 12 days later, it was still in the news, a long run for a controversy about a ballplayer who makes no policy.

Two sets of posts are at issue. In the first, Santander reposted a video of a Christian preacher who said there is "no such thing as kind Muslims." That claim fails on arithmetic alone. There are approximately two billion Muslims in the world, and the chair of Rebel News, Raheel Raza, is a Muslim who rejects the jihadi mentality.

The second set concerned Abdul El-Sayed, the Democratic senator-elect from Michigan. One caption read "America voted for Sharia last night!" and another read "Islam is not peaceful." Critics of El-Sayed argue that concern about his ideology is fair comment, and they point to a recent opinion piece in National Review.

In it, Andrew C. McCarthy called El-Sayed "the Gerry Adams of the Muslim Brotherhood" and wrote that he "implausibly denies ties to the Muslim Brotherhood." McCarthy described the Brotherhood, founded by the Egyptian teacher Hasan al-Banna in 1928, as "the most consequential global sharia-supremacist movement in modern history." He added: "That El-Sayed could win 2.5 million votes in Michigan should be shocking." Several Muslim-majority countries have banned the movement, including Egypt, where it began.

Toronto media did not treat the posts as a matter for debate. Toronto Life's headline read, "Anthony Santander has finally apologized for his Islamophobic Instagram posts." Now Toronto ran "'I should have been more thoughtful': Blue Jays' Anthony Santander apologizes for Islamophobic posts." The Toronto Star published "Prominent Muslim Major League Baseball executive sees opportunity for Blue Jays following Santander's Islamophobic posts." All three use the word "Islamophobic" as a description, not an allegation.

Santander has apologized. The club's recent history suggests that may not end the matter. Pitcher Anthony Bass was released by the Blue Jays in 2023 for allegedly making an anti-LGBT post, after he criticized Bud Light's advertising campaign with Dylan Mulvaney. Critics of the team see a pattern in which a player is made to apologize publicly and is then let go anyway.

The standard applied to Santander invites comparison with another file. Over the past year, Rebel News has reported on about a dozen Islamists working at some of Canada's biggest employers, among them Scotiabank, the Royal Bank, KPMG, Telus, Air Canada and the Greater Toronto Airports Authority. Rebel News reported that they went online to call for genocide against Jews and to embrace designated terrorist groups including Hamas, the Houthis, Hezbollah and the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps.

One of them was Amir Hossein Khademi, until recently a senior system analyst at Rogers Communications. Rebel News, alerted by Leviathan, reported that posts by Khademi blamed Jews for "killing kids and innocent people," stated that "everyone is sick of Jews like you," and said he would be "first in line" if Israel were ever invaded. Another post, Rebel News reported, showed the late Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah and missiles launching toward Israel under the caption "your time will come."

Those posts were public. By Rebel News' account, the companies acted only after it contacted their media relations departments for comment, and other news outlets did not pick up the stories. Santander, whatever the merits of what he shared, did not call for genocide or express support for a terrorist group.

If the Blue Jays do part with Santander, the cost will be considerable. He signed a five-year, US$92.5 million deal before the 2025 season and has appeared in only 54 games. He missed the entire 2026 season after surgery on his left shoulder, and he was paid throughout.


GUEST: Ezra Levant, with an update from Taiwan.

COMMENTS

Showing 4 Comments

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
  • Vince Smythe
    commented 2026-11-16 22:58:49 -0500
    Pussy
  • Roman Kierzek
    commented 2026-11-16 22:06:24 -0500 Flag
    Islam phobia shmobia, you go girl. Call em as you see em.
  • Jane Vandervliet
    commented 2026-11-16 21:05:58 -0500
    I am a woman and that is why I am Islamophobic. Islam treats women and girls abominaly. I don’t understand why any lefties support Gaza/Palestine crap especially feminist types. If Islamics got control they would impose Sharia Law which says women are worth half a man, that women need to be punished for their own rape, that men can have intercourse with really little girls as long as they don’t rupture the division of the vagina and annus, that women especially young women carry the honour of the family clan and they will be killed if they break that honour, that husband’s can beat their wives for disobedience. Islamic ‘heaven’ is a sex orgy for men but women generally don’t get to heaven because they are stupid. So, yah, I am Islamophobic and I will not apologize for writing this!
  • Bruce Atchison
    commented 2026-11-16 20:43:46 -0500 Flag
    What a double standard. Jihadists can spew the worst hatred about Jews and Christians while anybody describing what Islam is all about gets in trouble. I believe Islam is the Devil’s religion but I’m not tarring every Muslim as being satanic. That’s the difference.