Historian David Starkey warns Britain is fracturing after forgetting that nationhood takes generations

Starkey argues that nationhood is built over generations and cannot be granted by a passport, and that Britain has forgotten this. He warns that open frontiers, uneven justice and a hyper-liberal elite are pushing the country toward division.

BECOME A MEMBER

rn-plus

Rebel News +

Our most popular subscription
  • View RebelNews.com without ads
  • Includes 1 free week of RebelNews+
  • Access all RebelNews+ shows
  • Access Comments and RN+ features

$8

Per month CAD

Producers Club

Our top supporters
  • View RebelNews.com without ads
  • Includes 1 free week of RebelNews+
  • Access all RebelNews+ shows
  • Access Comments and RN+ features
  • Invites to producers club only events
  • Special discount at RebelNewsStore.com
  • Free gifts for members, like signed books

$22

Per month CAD


Article by Rebel News staff.

Tonight on The Ezra Levant Show: historian Dr. David Starkey argues that Britain's crisis is a crisis of forgetting, and that a nation cut off from its own inheritance loses the ability to tell the citizen from the stranger.

Starkey, who taught at the London School of Economics for 26 years and is best known for his work on Henry VIII, Elizabeth I and the British monarchy, builds his case on Edmund Burke. Burke answered the French Revolution by describing society as "a contract between the living, the dead, and those yet to be born." "We are not creatures of will. We're creatures of inheritance," Starkey says.

Britain, in his account, has lived through "an extraordinary change in our customs, our manners, our constitution, our way of living," and the schools share much of the blame. "The central task of a teacher is to transmit a culture," he says, but teachers came to see their duty as criticizing and reshaping, and modern teaching "abandoned the idea of knowledge. Indeed, it's very largely abandoned an idea of truth."

His central historical argument concerns time. He rejects the official narrative that Britain is a nation of immigrants, noting that DNA analysis suggests much of the population has been there since the Bronze Age. Romans, Anglo-Saxons and Danes came as invaders, Huguenots, Jews and Irish followed, and even the Norman Conquest, which he calls "colonial conquest of the most brutal sort," ended with conquerors and conquered becoming one people. "It is the effect of time," he says.

The monarchy illustrates the process. The royal family kept itself German for 200 years by marrying back to Germany, then changed its name from Saxe-Coburg to Windsor during the First World War and began marrying English men and women.

The same test of time shapes his view of Rishi Sunak, a man he calls "imbued with that old fashioned English concept of public duty." Yet Starkey argues Sunak cannot yet be called English because not enough time has gone by, though two or three generations may change that. The modern mistake, he says, is believing a passport alone makes someone British or Canadian.

Starkey calls the prevailing ideology "hyper liberalism" and says Canada, "remade by the Trudeaus to be a post nation nation," stood at its vanguard. His example is the Archbishop of Canterbury, who on the anniversary of the Sept. 11 attacks honoured a Pakistani imam who refused to let the archbishop, a woman, touch him, so the medal was placed on his wife, veiled in a face-concealing niqab. The award was later rescinded. Starkey calls the archbishop, a former chief nursing officer, "pig ignorant."

The deeper error, he argues, is treating Islam as a private faith when it is "a complete structure of life, law, politics." The idea of universal human rights assumes a universal human being, and that assumption led to the abandonment of frontiers and of the principle that "the first duty of the state is to distinguish between the citizen and the foreigner, and to protect the citizen." He describes Britain's rape gangs as extended families operating like a mafia, bound by clan loyalties the West will not acknowledge.

He warns of what he calls the Northern Ireland-ization of Britain. In Belfast, the Palestinian flag now flies beside the Irish tricolour and the Star of Israel beside the Union Jack. In Portsmouth, men from the Patriot Platform, a group organized by Danny Tommo, gathered in black clothing and face masks to resist the landing of an inflatable boat carrying about 100 people. "This is a very, very real risk," Starkey says of society fragmenting into rival vigilante groups.

The law, he argues, feeds that risk. At the time of the Southport riots, Starkey says, a masked crowd carrying baseball bats surrounded a pub in Birmingham's Sparkbrook district and beat one man so badly his liver ruptured. A Muslim police inspector then told them: "Come on, be sensible. Put your baseball bats away. Put them in the mosque." Citing the judge Tom Bingham, Starkey says human rights law is anti-democratic and counter-majoritarian. "It protects the minority at the expense of the majority," he says, and few people grasp that the law of England, which invented equality before the law, "had actually been deliberately skewed."

Born in 1945, Starkey says he has "lived through the most comfortable experience of human history, but it is manifestly coming to an end." The answer, he argues, is the one thing Kipling, Chesterton and T.S. Eliot each believed in and showed in very different ways: courage.


GUEST: Interview with historian Dr. David Starkey

Migrant Reports UK

Danny Tommo cut an empty migrant dinghy in the English Channel — and now he's in a cell without bail while every migrant on that boat gets a free lawyer. Rebel News is sending Alexa Lavoie to the UK to cover his court case and the rape gang protests the British media refuses to report honestly.

COMMENTS

Showing 8 Comments

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
  • Angela Watt
    commented 2026-09-26 11:51:24 -0400 Flag
    What I don’t understand is why Canadians are so oblivious to what is happening, not only in our own country, but world-wide. The Muslims are purposefully taking over wherever they can, having a dozen kids so they can populate a country & take over. If you read the Islamic dictates, they clearly state they want to “wash the world in blood”. We need another crusade because that’s why there was the first one – to get rid of the Muslim barbarians!! Now having said that, I realize that not all Muslims are extremists, but they won’t go against these extremists either so they’re complacent as well. We need more babies but white liberal women feel that children are a burden & not something to cherish.
  • Lib Ferguson
    commented 2026-09-26 10:14:46 -0400 Flag
    Hi Nellis. I agree that diversity causes division. I know that Canada has an identity underneath all the immigration gobshites. As Dr. Starkey said we have to be courageous. I’m Irish blood … I’m ready to raise a little hell!!Cheers
  • Nellis Foesier
    commented 2026-09-26 09:29:32 -0400 Flag
    Dr. Starkey was speaking on historical immigration. This was a melting pot immigration where people came to the country and contributed to the society as a whole. Since the 1970s in Canada we have had Multiculturalism which promotes the idea of division. The immigrants are told that they do not have to adopt Canadian culture or language and can carry on with the culture that they have come from. The result of this policy was directly addressed by Justin Trudeau’s comment that Canada has no core identity. We did have a core identity when melting pot immigration was the norm. This type of immigration policy seems to be the norm now in most western countries. Diversity causes division, not unity.
  • Matt Abrahams
    commented 2026-09-26 01:01:54 -0400 Flag
    The title of the Kipling poem you mentioned (with the line, “When the English began to hate” at the end of each stanza) is “The Beginnings”.
  • Bernhard Jatzeck
    commented 2026-09-25 23:19:45 -0400 Flag
    Apparently, we can thank Tony Blair for that. He encouraged “migration” just so that “new” Labour could rub the right’s noses in it. (Doesn’t that sound like a certain country we’re all familiar with?)
  • Lib Ferguson
    commented 2026-09-25 22:19:47 -0400 Flag
    Amazing historian. I agree courage is important … to stand up for what is right. To stand up for Christianity. But these come with consequences such as labeled racist etc – jail, fines. We must be courageous to defend who we are and what we represent. I’m a historian and true knowledge is power!
  • Jane Vandervliet
    commented 2026-09-25 21:35:08 -0400 Flag
    So Ezra is correct; Kipling did write When the English Begin to Hate. I sure hope the English determine to do so again to save themselves from the misogynistic kufar-hating Muslims who have invaded Britain.
  • Bruce Atchison
    commented 2026-09-25 21:22:46 -0400 Flag
    We’re heading for a new dark age where Islam rules and freedom dies. Like that camel pushing its nose further into the tent, we who benefitted from European heritage will find ourselves pushed aside. Islam is thee biggest threat to humanity. Must we become like Iran before we realize that?