Western premiers feud over pipeline: who's in the right?

Sheila Gunn Reid and Lise Merle weigh in on the public spat between Alberta, Saskatchewan and British Columbia's leaders after Danielle Smith proposed a new pipeline, and was backed by Scott Moe, only to see David Eby reject the project.

Premier David Eby has been on the defensive since Alberta proposed a new pipeline project that would reach the shores of British Columbia. Support for new pipelines is broadly popular among Canadians, with polls finding a majority are in support of new developments.

An informal poll run by Kelowna-based news outlet Castanet found overwhelming support from its readers, with 81% supporting such developments.

But Premier Eby pumped the brakes on Alberta Premier Danielle Smith's proposal for a new pipeline, suggesting this could “upset the fragile consensus” among the provinces.

Premier Smith called Eby's efforts to block the project “un-Canadian” and “unconstitutional,” an assertion that was backed by Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe.

On Wednesday's Buffalo Roundtable livestream, hosts Sheila Gunn Reid and Lise Merle discussed the ongoing spat between Western Canada's premiers.

Eby's comments are directed to a small number of “very privileged, unionized NDP supporters who lap up his garbage,” Lise said. “Scott Moe and Danielle Smith are having none of this.”

Provincial leaders publicly feuding like this is “very rare,” Lise added. “This is a spectacular meltdown by David Eby, and I think he's showing his true colours.”

“We want bad laws repealed so that we can have, once again, private sector investment,” Sheila said of Albertans' support for a new development. “Right now, it is a lot easier — I say it all the time — to pay off the local Christian kidnapping warlord in Nigeria or Algeria to get your energy project done than it is to deal with Mark Carney's insane regulatory regime.”

Comparing Canada to the U.S., where shale oil is located in southern Saskatchewan and North Dakota, Sheila pointed out that businesses are presented an option: “Mark Carney's Canada or North Dakota? Guess where they're going to drill in the same oil field; it's not Canada.”

Please help Rebel News stand up for the West!

Ottawa’s been screwing the West for decades — Trudeau's carbon taxes, Carney’s smug elitism, and laws like Bill C-69 that sabotage our prosperity. The message from the East? Shut up, pay up, and stay in your place. We’re done with that. And we think you are too. That's why Rebel News is launching a campaign to give Albertans and the West a voice — and we need your help to kick it off. Please help us fund a province-wide poll on Alberta independence, emergency townhalls, and fearless journalism that tells the truth about how badly Ottawa treats the West. If you're fed up with being trampled by the Laurentian elite, chip in now. We’re not taking it anymore!

Amount
$
Donation frequency

Livestream Clips

Catch the most impactful clips from our daily news livestream, Rebel Roundup, featuring breaking stories, bold opinions, and exclusive insights from our top reporters. Stay informed and never miss a moment—watch now!

https://www.rebelnews.com/live

COMMENTS

Showing 2 Comments

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
  • Bernhard Jatzeck
    commented 2025-10-09 21:42:28 -0400
    I lived in the Vancouver area many years ago and, because I moved there from Alberta, I was seen and treated as if I was a rube, a bumpkin, a hillbilly, and a knuckle-dragger.

    Eby displayed that same attitude towards Smith.
  • Bruce Atchison
    commented 2025-10-09 15:37:36 -0400
    Smith is right and Eby is way wrong.