Amish score big legal win after outrageous ArriveCan fines

Sheila Gunn Reid and David Menzies react to an Amish community in Ontario scoring a big legal win after receiving outrageous fines related to the pandemic-era ArriveCan app, thanks to support from civil liberties charity The Democracy Fund.

An Amish community in Ontario has won a major legal victory after more than $38,000 in pandemic-era fines linked to the ArriveCan app were waived. The Amish, who do not use modern technology, were charged under the Quarantine Act following their re-entry into the country at the Niagara Falls border.

Many were convicted in absentia, never properly notified of their trial dates or charges, and subsequently saddled with tens of thousands in fines, Rebel News previously reported.

On Monday's Rebel Roundup livestream, hosts Sheila Gunn Reid and David Menzies reacted to the good news.

“The idea that this proceeded as far as it did is insane,” said Sheila, praising the work of The Democracy Fund and its donors who helped crowdfund the Amish's legal defence.

The government overreach in this case was “outrageous,” David said. “The cherry on this sordid sundae is this: ArriveCan did not work,” he added, with Sheila noting the exorbitant cost and highlighting how it erroneously sent individuals to quarantine.

“Anybody facing any of these fines should have their money given back and everything wiped clean,” Sheila declared. “The thing didn't work; it was a scam from the beginning.”

HELP THE AMISH

A small, peaceful Amish community in Ontario was hit with hundreds of thousands of dollars in COVID fines because they didn’t comply with the government’s ArriveCAN app — an app they had no way to use, on phones they don’t own. Most never even knew they’d been convicted until liens appeared on their farms. Your donations are working: The Democracy Fund has identified 32 affected families, and 24 have now had their fines stayed or zeroed out entirely. But eight families were refused, and their appeal is now before the Ontario Court of Justice. One family alone still owes $13,000 plus interest — a devastating sum for people who live on subsistence farming and the cash sale of homemade jams, pickles and quilts. Please chip in right here to fund their legal defence. Your donation goes directly to legal representation to fight these unjust fines. (The Democracy Fund is a registered Canadian charity, so you’ll receive a tax receipt for your contribution!)

Amount
$

Donation frequency

Livestream Clips

Catch the most impactful clips from our daily news livestream, Rebel Roundup, featuring breaking stories, bold opinions, and exclusive insights from our top reporters. Stay informed and never miss a moment—watch now!

https://www.rebelnews.com/live

COMMENTS

Showing 1 Comment

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
  • Bruce Atchison
    commented 2025-06-10 21:27:18 -0400
    It boggles my mind how ignorant bureaucrats can be. I bet nobody thought to phone the Amish farmers on a landline. Some mid-level or senior bureaucrat must have just given an order to put liens on the farms and all the little brown-nosers just followed orders. So will those responsible for this stupidity pay for their blunder? I doubt it. Stupidity is an asset when working for the feds.