Parliament to study if refugee claimants, illegals receive ‘better health care’ than Canadians

Medical expenses for refugee claimants and illegals is budgeted at $598 million this year.

 

The Commons health committee voted 5-4 last week for a special audit of the half-billion-dollar medical fund for illegal immigrants and refugee claimants to determine if their coverage is better than that of taxpayers.

Conservative MP Dan Mazier, citing that “Six-and-a-half million Canadians don’t have a family doctor,” moved for the Auditor General to “conduct a comprehensive audit of the Interim Federal Health Program to examine the significant increase in costs, usage and impacts on provincial health care systems.”

The program covering medical expenses for refugee claimants and illegal immigrants is budgeted at $598 million this year, as reported by Blacklock’s. Last year, 426,750 people qualified for coverage, a 400% increase in under 10 years, as reported to the health committee.

Conservative MP Burton Bailey claimed asylum seekers and illegal immigrants receive better health care than the Canadian taxpayers funding it — a claim Assistant Deputy Immigration Minister Soyoung Park disputed.

“I am not sure I would describe it as better health care,” said Assistant Deputy Park. “I sure would,” replied MP Bailey. “I sure would, when I look at the billing.”

MP Bailey suggested that the system, as it is, is being abused, stating that individuals with “bogus asylum claims” are receiving Canadian taxpayer-funded health care, including dental, vision, medical devices, and mental health services, benefits that many Canadians lack.

Liberal MP Doug Eyolfson opposed calling rejected refugee claimants “bogus,” even though former immigration minister Marc Miller denounced foreigners who “exploit the generosity of Canadians” with illegitimate claims.

Liberal MP Marcus Powlowski criticized the motion as misguided, arguing the committee should focus on actual health issues instead of appealing to a “Conservative notion” that Canada is “wasting money on these foreigners.” He disagreed with devoting time to an issue designed to appeal to a base wanting to hear that “too many foreigners” use Canadian health services.

Immigration Minister Lena Diab told the Commons health committee on November 18 that “Many who are arriving are doctors," offering no figures, while discussing immigration's health-care impact. This year, the Immigration Levels Plan will allow over one million foreigners to enter Canada.

Diab avoided questions about health-care capacity and unprecedented immigration levels. When asked about Canadians without a family doctor, she labelled it a “provincial” issue, despite Health Canada's previous 5.7 million estimate.

SecondStreet figures show over 3.2 million Canadians await health care, potentially closer to 5.1 million due to incomplete provincial data and missing reports from P.E.I. and Yukon.

Refugee claims have surged fivefold since 2022, from 54,000 to 290,000, creating a 44-month backlog, given the current capacity of 80,000 finalized cases per year.

Canada intends to admit 1.14 million new permanent residents, projecting a total increase of 2.2 million newcomers (temporary and permanent) over the next three years.

PETITION: Net-Zero Immigration!

16,891 signatures
Goal: 20,000 signatures

Canadians are suffering as a result of uncontrolled immigration under the leadership of Prime Minister Mark Carney. The cost of living has soared, there's inadequate housing, and our social welfare system is buckling at the seams. Please sign our petition here to demand that Mark Carney stop the unmitigated influx of immigrants to Canada!

Will you sign?

Alex Dhaliwal

Journalist and Writer

Alex Dhaliwal is a Political Science graduate from the University of Calgary. He has actively written on relevant Canadian issues with several prominent interviews under his belt.

Help fund Alex's journalism!

COMMENTS

Showing 3 Comments

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
  • Fran G
    commented 2025-11-26 14:42:31 -0500
    Send them packing on a plane back to where they came from. Ya Trump. I would be overjoyed to have him instead of the slimy one we have in Canada.
  • Peter Wrenshall
    commented 2025-11-25 23:40:03 -0500
    Anyone who is not a citizen or permanent resident should be eligible only for emergency medical services. In the case of illegal migrants, treat the emergency, then send them packing.
  • Bruce Atchison
    commented 2025-11-24 19:34:30 -0500
    To hell with these obvious studies! Isn’t it obvious to even a casual observer that more sick people means longer wait times and fewer health resources?