Alberta Fact Check: Alberta's big-city mayors have bigger problems than Alberta's referendum

The mayors of Calgary, Edmonton, and Red Deer are calling on Albertans to oppose October's independence referendum.

 

source: X / JeromyYYC

Calgary Mayor Jeromy Farkas has joined Edmonton Mayor Andrew Knack and Red Deer Mayor Cindy Jefferies in a video urging Albertans to vote against Alberta's October independence referendum.

The mayors warn that even discussing Alberta's future could create uncertainty and threaten economic prosperity. "Leaving Canada would create uncertainty for Alberta’s economy, threaten jobs and investment, and put at risk the quality of life we’ve worked so hard to build," Farkas wrote on X.

But before Albertans take constitutional advice from municipal politicians, they might reasonably ask how things are going in the cities those politicians were elected to run.

Take a walk through downtown Edmonton.

The city continues to struggle with open-air drug use, homelessness encampments, transit violence, repeat offenders and the ongoing fallout from the opioid crisis. Businesses and residents have spent years sounding the alarm about deteriorating public safety and disorder in the downtown core.

Red Deer faces many of the same challenges. The city has become one of Alberta's most visible examples of the devastation caused by fentanyl addiction. Public drug use, homelessness, crime and chronic disorder remain persistent concerns for residents and downtown business owners.

Calgary residents continue to contend with homelessness, addiction, encampments, public disorder and concerns about safety in parts of the downtown core and on public transit.

These are not federal responsibilities. They are not constitutional questions. They are municipal responsibilities.

Yet instead of focusing on the problems directly affecting residents, Alberta's mayors have chosen to campaign against a provincial referendum that simply asks Albertans what they think about Alberta's future.

The referendum is not a vote to separate from Canada.

It is a vote on whether Alberta should pursue independence.

Albertans can vote yes.

Albertans can vote no.

That is democracy.

Municipalities are not sovereign governments. Alberta creates municipalities, defines their powers, changes their boundaries, amalgamates them and, if it chooses, can dissolve them altogether through legislation. The authority exercised by Calgary, Edmonton and Red Deer ultimately flows from the Province of Alberta itself.

Yet municipal politicians whose powers exist only because the province grants them have decided to intervene in a debate about the future constitutional status of the province that created them.

Albertans can make up their own minds about independence.

But before Calgary, Edmonton and Red Deer's mayors lecture the province about democracy and constitutional questions, they might want to focus on the boarded-up storefronts, the addiction crisis, the encampments and the public disorder that continue to plague the downtown cores they were elected to manage.

Unlike the referendum, Albertans are already living with them every day.

Help fund our independent reporting on Alberta's independence movement!

Rebel News is stepping up where the legacy media have failed. We've assigned Tamara Lich to follow the Alberta independence movement as it unfolds — not from a government-funded newsroom in Toronto, but on the ground with the people actually shaping it. We don’t take a cent of the Liberals' media bailouts, which means we rely entirely on viewers like you to make this journalism possible. If you want Albertans to have a fair voice in a debate the establishment would rather crush, please chip in today and help us keep this reporting going strong.

Amount
$

Donation frequency

Sheila Gunn Reid

Chief Reporter

Sheila Gunn Reid is the Editor-in-Chief, Alberta Bureau Chief, member of the board of directors, and host of The Gunn Show at Rebel News. Sheila also serves as President of the Independent Press Gallery of Canada. A mother of three and longtime conservative activist, Sheila is the author of bestselling books, including her most recent release, Independence Blueprint: What Alberta Can Learn From Quebec.

https://mybook.to/sheila

COMMENTS

Showing 3 Comments

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
  • Bernhard Jatzeck
    commented 2026-06-08 23:55:37 -0400
    Bruce:

    I have similar memories of Edmonton’s downtown area. It’s been a long time since the city had a council that was willing to keep things safe there.

    When we came to Edmonton in the mid-1950s, downtown was a place to go shopping or see a movie. But many of those establishments have either gone out of business (e. g., Woodward’s, Eatons, the Paramount and Odeon theatres) or went elsewhere in the city. There are lots of reasons why that happened.

    Nowadays, there’s not much reason to go downtown unless it’s for work. I can’t remember the last time I went there as I can get most of what I need in my part of the city. Those businesses and services are within walking distance or a short bike ride from where I live.
  • Bruce Atchison
    commented 2026-06-08 23:04:59 -0400
    55 years ago, downtown Edmonton was quite safe. Now I wouldn’t go there if somebody paid me. These mayors need a check up from the neck up. They should stay in their municipal lane instead of meddling in provincial politics.
  • Bernhard Jatzeck
    commented 2026-06-08 15:48:05 -0400
    Edmonton’s becoming a rough place to live. One auto glass firm I dealt with a while ago told me that they do a lot of smash-and-grab business.

    Even in my apartment building, a number of tenants have had their Amazon shipments opened and the contents pinched.