Conservative caucus faces leadership crossroads after election defeat
The caucus will convene this Tuesday, its first meeting since leader Pierre Poilievre lost his seat, leaving many to wonder whether he will remain or face a leadership review.
In a pivotal moment for the Conservative Party, the caucus will convene this coming Tuesday for the first time since their federal election loss, as revealed by an internal memo obtained by CTV News.
The meeting memo says that it will “exercise provisions” from the Reform Act under Section 49 of the Parliament of Canada Act; what transpires could shape the party’s future, including a potential leadership review for Pierre Poilievre.
The 2015 Reform Act, championed by Ontario MP Michael Chong, empowers the caucus to vote on four key internal powers, including the ability to oust their leader and appoint an interim replacement. To trigger a leadership review, 20% of the caucus must formally agree, followed by a majority vote via secret ballot.
This mechanism famously led to Erin O’Toole’s removal in 2022 after the 2021 election defeat.
Despite losing his own seat and the Conservatives’ fourth failed bid against the Liberals, Poilievre appears to have retained significant support. Former leader Andrew Scheer, re-elected in Regina-Qu’Appelle, told CTV’s Power Play that Poilievre is “absolutely” staying, praising him as a “fighter” for Canadians overlooked by the government.
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith reaffirmed her unwavering support for Poilievre, the day after his electoral defeat and loss of his parliamentary seat.
Premier Smith says Conservative Party Leader Pierre Poilievre should stay on as leader following last night's loss.
— Rebel News (@RebelNewsOnline) April 29, 2025
"I don't see any reason why he shouldn't stay on," she says. pic.twitter.com/WJ7vIDf3gN
The Conservatives secured 8,086,051 votes in the 2025 snap election — 41.3% of the total — marking their strongest showing since Brian Mulroney’s 1988 majority. Yet, the Liberals edged them out with 43.7% of the vote. Poilievre is reportedly rallying grassroots support and eyeing a return to the House of Commons, though this would require an MP to resign and a byelection to take place, a process that could take months.
In 2022, Elections Canada redistributed the riding represented by @PierrePoilievre. A new riding, Kanata, was created, while the remaining part of the former Kanata–Carleton riding was merged into the redefined Carleton riding.
— Alexandra Lavoie (@ThevoiceAlexa) April 30, 2025
Since 2015, Kanata–Carleton had consistently… pic.twitter.com/s3rMaWD3YM
As the caucus prepares to meet, the question looms: will they rally behind Poilievre or push for a change in leadership?


COMMENTS
-
Bernhard Jatzeck commented 2025-05-03 17:21:57 -0400Fran:
My memories of the Conservatives goes back to the Diefenbaker PCs. Ever since Dalton Camp pulled his “Night of the Long Knives” stunt and sent Dief packing as party leader, that movement hasn’t had anybody truly convincing who could win over the people.
Stanfield was portrayed as a bumbler in that football photo. Clarke, though inexperienced, was never allowed to govern (thanks for nothing, Broadbent!). Mulroney ended up betraying western Canada. Kim! was a disaster and Stockwell Day should have known better than to try Sea-Dooing.
I wasn’t impressed with Harper and, as for the rest, well, I don’t have to go into detail. I hedged my bets, so to speak, with Poilieve, waiting until he would disappoint me. -
Fran g commented 2025-05-03 16:42:50 -0400Dont agree with you Bernard. Pollieve is our man. He will win after brainwashed people start seeing huge lies and corruption from Carnage. Next time in a year or so I do however wish Pollieve would talk more about mass immigration and Crooks many scandals et…………….I live in Alberta, I am and always will be Canadian, I strongly choose to stay and fight.
-
Bruce Atchison commented 2025-05-02 21:27:24 -0400I hope Pierre Poilievre wins support to stay on as leader. He’s so much better than Erin O’Toole. Realize too that Trump inadvertently gave Carney ammunition to fight the Conservatives by fear mongering about the 51st state. There was nothing Poilievre could do about Trump’s jabs at Trudeau. I also hope malcontents will be shouted down in the Conservative party. There are always those big egos who figure they ought to be leader.
-
Bernhard Jatzeck commented 2025-05-02 21:21:09 -0400He ran a weak campaign. Rather than emphasize questions about glaring uncertainties in Carney’s background, he got sucked into the “Orange Man Bad” circus.
The result is that Canadians voted for a phony “saviour” and, when the skeletons in his closet start falling out, they will claim they didn’t know anything and didn’t see it happen.
The apple interview worked only once, but it wasn’t enough to win the election. -
Leslie Paradis commented 2025-05-02 18:06:05 -0400If they don’t keep Pierre I’ll be disgusted !
-
Nancy Miller commented 2025-05-02 13:01:20 -0400Pierre did nothing wrong but be honest . He’s not a manipulator like the grand master of lies MC
Considering Donald Trump goes against WEF and their agenda I quite shocked how he’s tied to carney