Carney dances around residential school 'denialism' issue
Sheila Gunn Reid and Tamara Ugolini react to Mark Carney's response to a reporter's question about his father's views on residential schools after comments from the Liberal leader's late father resurfaced.
Liberal Leader Mark Carney recently distanced himself from past comments made by his late father, Robert Carney, who was a principal at an Indian day school in the Northwest Territories.
The elder Carney defended the residential school system, acknowledging there were instances of abuse but saying it “cannot be viewed as being wholly destructive or ill-intended,” as CBC reported.
“I love my father, but I don't share those views,” Carney said when asked about the past statements, describing residential schools as a “long, painful part of our history.”
On Monday's Rebel Roundup livestream, hosts Sheila Gunn Reid and Tamara Ugolini shared their thoughts on Carney's response when he was asked about his father's resurfaced remarks.
The reporter's question didn't approach the issue from the correct angle, noted Sheila.
“He can easily say, 'well I don't agree with my dad' — trust me, I don't agree with my family on a lot of things,” she acknowledged. “But I think it should come down to: do you think his viewpoint should be outlawed and criminalized? Because that is the state of discussion here in Canada.”
Were residential schools “evil,” wondered Sheila, given the Liberals' efforts to criminalize discussion and debate surrounding the issue. “Then, you would have to admit your dad was just an evil part of an evil thing ... or were their good people working in the system? Because you can't really have it both ways.”
Tamara, meanwhile, referred the audience to a recent Rebel News report from Drea Humphrey, which featured the perspective of an anonymous Kamloops band member who attended the controversial former residential school and viewed it as a positive experience.
“When Carney's committing to continuing to truth and reconciliation, now is that just throwing more money at it hoping it eventually goes away?” Tamara asked.Â
“There were instances where horrific things took place in some of these schools,” she continued, “but there were other instances where that was not the case at all.”
The claim of 215 unmarked mass graves at the former Kamloops Indian Residential School remains unproven.
“The whole idea of truth and reconciliation cannot occur without having those clear instances of truth and honesty being reported to the public. Just by throwing money at things, nothing is going to get better.”

Livestream Clips
Catch the most impactful clips from our daily news livestream, Rebel Roundup, featuring breaking stories, bold opinions, and exclusive insights from our top reporters. Stay informed and never miss a moment—watch now!
https://www.rebelnews.com/live
COMMENTS
-
Bernhard Jatzeck commented 2025-04-08 23:24:47 -0400Carnage will, no doubt, distance himself from his father’s activities by claiming he had some Damascus Road conversion to wokeness.
-
Bruce Atchison commented 2025-04-08 22:34:35 -0400As usual, Liberals lie. Mark Carney doesn’t want to be known as the son of a day school principal who said the native schools weren’t some sort of killing fields.