Debunking myths in new residential school documentary 'Sugarcane': Michelle Stirling

Michelle Stirling tells The Gunn Show that critics who reviewed the film came away with a twisted impression of Canadian history, a narrative she warns is going to be “very hard to counter” due to its spread across legacy media outlets.

Watch new episodes of The Gunn Show every Wednesday when you become a subscriber to RebelNews+. Start your free trial today!


Rocklinc Investment Partners

SPONSOR | With the woke banks on one side and cookie-cutter, multi-national wealth managers on the other, it can seem like the conservative Canadian is out of options. Call Rocklinc Investment Partners, Canada’s premier conservative money manager: www.RockLinc.com

 

'Sugarcane', an acclaimed 2024 documentary from National Geographic is set to be screened on the network on December 9 before releasing on Disney+ and Hulu. The film has received praise from critics over its examination of residential schools in Canada.

But the narrative in the documentary isn't quite what it seems, says Michelle Stirling, who produced a mini documentary debunking the claims made in the film.

She joined Sheila Gunn Reid on Wednesday's episode of The Gunn Show for a discussion about the United Nations' latest climate summit, where the pair also examined what Sugarcane gets wrong.

“What's happened is, two young filmmakers have made a documentary that takes two true stories and conflates them and turns it into one big lie,” Michelle told Sheila, who said her mini documentary “deconstructs these lies.”

Critics reviewing Sugarcane, Michelle said, “definitely get the impression that priests systematically raped students, burned unwanted babies in the incinerator, there was infanticide going on.”

This, she explained, is the critics “creating a meta narrative worldwide about Canada and Indian residential schools that is completely untrue.”

“But it's going to be very hard to counter it,” she warned.

Watch Michelle Stirling's mini documentary, The Bitter Roots of "Sugarcane", below:

BECOME A MEMBER

rn-plus

Rebel News +

Our most popular subscription
  • View RebelNews.com without ads
  • Includes 1 free week of RebelNews+
  • Access all RebelNews+ shows
  • Access Comments and RN+ features

$8

Per month CAD

Producers Club

Our top supporters
  • View RebelNews.com without ads
  • Includes 1 free week of RebelNews+
  • Access all RebelNews+ shows
  • Access Comments and RN+ features
  • Invites to producers club only events
  • Special discount at RebelNewsStore.com
  • Free gifts for members, like signed books

$22

Per month CAD

Rebel News

Staff

Articles written by staff at Rebel News to help tell the other side of the story. 

COMMENTS

Be the first to comment

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.