Government House leader warns of potential election if budget voted down

MacKinnon urged opposition leaders to reconsider their "unreasonable" demands and prevent an election by committing to the November 4 budget.

 

The Canadian Press / Adrian Wyld

The Carney government's House leader expressed concern Tuesday that its first budget may not pass, citing opposition demands as "political games." He warned Canadians could return to polls in six months, as reported by the Toronto Star.

Steven MacKinnon conveyed his displeasure over Parliament's handling of the upcoming budget, accusing the Conservatives and Bloc Québécois of not taking it "seriously" while Canadians seek "certainty."

Two weeks before his first budget, Prime Minister Mark Carney's minority Liberal government faces a critical confidence test. With another election possible without support from an opposition party, MacKinnon stated, "We have a minority government, but we believe we have a mandate."

MacKinnon urged opposition leaders to reconsider their "unreasonable" demands and prevent an election by committing to the November 4 budget. Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre stated he would meet Carney to discuss.

Poilievre urged Carney to deliver an "affordable budget" with broad tax cuts and a deficit below $42 billion. He also called for the elimination of "hidden taxes on food," including the industrial carbon tax on fertilizer and farm equipment, which are driving up grocery prices.

MacKinnon called the target “unattainable” and nearly $30 billion below the Parliamentary Budget Officer’s estimate.

Meanwhile, the Bloc Québécois demands billions in new spending for health, seniors' benefits, and nearly $1 billion in carbon tax rebates for Quebecers. These 18 demands, six "non-negotiable" yet "difficult to obtain," are "far removed" from daily life and "hard to follow," according to MacKinnon, making their support for Carney's fiscal restraint unlikely.

Interim NDP leader Don Davies has not made specific demands for Carney but called for “substantial investment” in jobs, health care, and housing, stating his party wouldn't back an "austerity" budget. He confirmed Tuesday that his caucus would analyze the budget before deciding, but clarified the NDP is not afraid of an election.

Amidst partisan chaos and U.S. tariff uncertainty, Prime Minister Carney will deliver a speech today on his Liberal government's first budget, expected to include spending cuts, new initiatives, and an expanded federal deficit.

The Liberal platform projected a $62.3 billion deficit this fiscal year, surpassing last year's $61.9 billion and the 2008 financial crisis ($55.6 billion). Carney criticized his predecessor for deficit spending before dropping the writ, then announced $129 billion in new deficit-increasing measures, including an income tax cut.

The former central banker delayed the spring budget, stating on May 18 that a "comprehensive, effective, ambitious, prudent budget" would be delivered in the fall.

Opposition parties and taxpayer advocates criticized the Prime Minister for lacking specific plans after the government announced no budget before the summer recess.

"Failing to even present a budget is a huge crack in Prime Minister Mark Carney's credibility," said Franco Terrazzano, CTF Federal Director. "You can't be credible with the finances if you can’t even bother to put together a budget.”

Poilievre agreed with the advocate, stating, "a budget is a plan," and if Carney "does indeed have a plan, … then he would introduce a budget so that Canadians know exactly what the finances are."

The government last failed to present a budget in the pandemic year of 2020. Parliament has not passed a Budget Implementation Act since June 19, 2024, stalled by Conservative filibusters over document disclosure related to a green technology fund. 

This marks the longest stretch without a budget since the 1960s and the first non-COVID-related instance in over two decades, which has been called "extremely unusual."

Please help me stop Mark Carney — before it’s too late!

Mark Carney wasn’t elected — he was installed by the global elites. And now that he’s in charge, they think they’ve won. But not if we have anything to say about it. While the bought-and-paid-for media slobber over their new golden boy, we’re hitting the streets, digging into his World Economic Forum playbook, and calling out the radical agenda they’re trying to ram down Canada’s throat. This is the fight of our lives — and we’re not backing down. Help us keep our reporters on the ground, our billboard truck on the move, and our message uncensored. Pitch in now if you want to stop Mark Carney before he does irreversible damage.

Amount
$
Donation frequency

Alex Dhaliwal

Journalist and Writer

Alex Dhaliwal is a Political Science graduate from the University of Calgary. He has actively written on relevant Canadian issues with several prominent interviews under his belt.

Help fund Alex's journalism!

COMMENTS

Showing 4 Comments

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
  • Fran G
    commented 2025-10-31 17:55:06 -0400
    I strongly agree Allan, top pre and current libs should all be in prison. When Pollievre gets in we can get rid of corrupt judges, lawyers, supreme court, high ranking RCMP, mainstream media, top c0vid medical monsters etc etc. Wouldnt that be glorious. And a big part of the pleasure would be to have the libs pay back what they stole from Canadian taxpayers. Maybe we would be out of debt.
  • Allan Young
    commented 2025-10-23 19:31:10 -0400
    As per an election ? The Liberal’s have painted themselves into a corner with their spending and corrupt un accountability of money. She’s supposedly gone now but just ask Katherine McKinnon where the $200billion she was in charge of went.
    They’ve painted themselves into a corner. They don’t even know where to start because the piggy bank is hollow & asking for interest payments. GDP over 10 years, not one is like 0.5 % ? Please correct me ?
    The Liberal’s are literally WISHING for an election, so they don’t have to have ever done their jobs correctly. Buddy’s and favour’s are fully satisfied, pockets brimming .
    As a Taxpayer, I don’t care the cost. I want accountability of everyone in the Liberal and NDP Gov’t coalition’s to pay if they have wronged Canadian’s.
    We know whoever takes over and gives responsible Gov’t, the cuts will need to be balanced but deep. We all start paying now for the spend crazy Liberal’s & their WOKE/WEF Ideologies !
  • Bernhard Jatzeck
    commented 2025-10-22 21:43:28 -0400
    Waydaminnit—Carney’s drawn up a budget? How did he find the time with all his foreign gallivanting?
  • Bruce Atchison
    commented 2025-10-22 21:33:11 -0400
    BRING IT ON! We need an election to get the Liberals out. Only regime change will put the country back onto the right path.