Leaked audio reveals ‘pressure from Quebec’ fuels gun confiscation scheme

During a 20-minute discreetly recorded conversation about the government's “buyback” program, Minister Gary Anandasangaree revealed the plan launches Tuesday.

 

The Canadian Press / Adrian Wyld

Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree has admitted to making "misguided" comments in a leaked audio recording, where he claimed Mark Carney's government is pushing the Trudeau-era gun ban and buyback due to Quebec's electoral demands.

During a 20-minute conversation about the government's “buyback” program, discreetly recorded by a tenant who is a gun owner, Minister Anandasangaree revealed details about the plan at his Toronto rental property.

Anandasangaree promised his tenant he'd cover any federal compensation shortfall for his banned guns and, jokingly, offered to bail him out for non-compliance, despite insisting police would enforce the program and arrests wouldn't be necessary.

Online clips of Sunday's conversation circulated after the man shared it with the Canadian Coalition for Firearm Rights. The Toronto Star obtained the full recording, confirming its authenticity with the man, who sought anonymity due to fear of repercussions but believed the content was in the public interest.

Anandasangaree affirmed his unequivocal support for the program, in comment to the Star, stating its critical role in combating crime and removing guns. The Prime Minister's Office offered no further comment.

Anandasangaree acknowledged the unknowingly recorded conversation, stating, “I make a point to speak with Canadians who do not support our approach, to listen to their concerns and ensure they understand their options in this voluntary buyback program.” 

The minister notes the gun “buyback” program benefits the Liberals in Quebec, where it's a major electoral issue for voters. He claimed he'd take a "very different approach" if he could restart, but insists it was a campaign promise to be kept.

The Liberal government's gun "buyback" pilot project launches Tuesday in Cape Breton, N.S., according to Anandasangaree. Federal documents show the government is funding Cape Breton police just over 100,000 until March 2026 to help confiscate legal firearms.

Anandasangaree was repeatedly questioned on why the Carney government proceeded with the program despite most gun crimes involving illegal weapons. 

The Trudeau government initially banned around 1,500 firearm makes and models in 2020 after a Nova Scotia mass shooting involving stolen and smuggled weapons. The prohibited list expanded to over 2,000 in March.

When the tenant questioned the logic, Anandasangaree replied, “Don’t ask me to explain the logic to you on this, OK?” The man interjected, “But we’re not the problem, Gary,” defending legal gun owners, to which Anandasangaree responded, “I realize that.”

A 2023 Public Safety report found that most legal gun owners view federal firearm confiscation as a wasteful policy that doesn't target actual illicit gun crime, which they attribute to gangs and organized crime.

The minister promised a different approach, moving forward, which includes new criminal justice measures, including bail reform and harsher illegal firearm penalties. 

Alberta and Saskatchewan police earlier stated it would not participate in the gun “buyback” program, while Ontario deemed it a low priority, citing a lack of provincial police resources.

The National Police Federation also said that collecting firearms from legal owners would divert resources from addressing illegal firearm use.

Tell Carney: Keep your hands off our guns!

50,533 signatures
Goal: 100,000 signatures

The federal government must stop punishing law-abiding gun owners and keep their hands off our guns. If you agree, please sign the petition on this page.

Will you sign?

Alex Dhaliwal

Journalist and Writer

Alex Dhaliwal is a Political Science graduate from the University of Calgary. He has actively written on relevant Canadian issues with several prominent interviews under his belt.

Help fund Alex's journalism!

COMMENTS

Showing 2 Comments

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
  • Bernhard Jatzeck
    commented 2025-09-22 21:36:17 -0400
    I used to support gun control because I thought it was a matter of public safety. Many years ago, my views changed and now I’m against it. It became clear to me that the real issues are the freedom of citizens and the limits of government.
  • Bruce Atchison
    commented 2025-09-22 17:51:36 -0400
    Why should non gun owners care? Because the government will classify other forms of property as “dangerous” too. They already want to end the sales of new fossil-fuel vehicles. Someday, if they are allowed to, they’ll grab those vehicles and who knows what else. It’s why we who don’t own guns must care and help defend gun owners. Firearms are a tool like any other tool.