York University Student Centre cancels talk by MP Garnett Genuis — was it because he's Conservative?
Universities should be — and used to be — marketplaces of ideas. Now they seem to be gated free speech zones controlled by politicized unions or administrators — or 'student centres.'
At York University in north Toronto, the war on free speech continues to rage. Well, at least certain types of free speech.
Case in point: Recently, the York University Student Centre actually banned a Canadian Member of Parliament from speaking at York University!
Garnett Genuis is a member of the Official Opposition, and he wanted to have an informal chat with students about jobs, housing, and the economy.
But Genuis never did get to speak. Why? Well, most likely because he’s a Conservative. And apparently, right-of-centre ideology might be a wee bit too offensive to the hothouse flowers on campus — at least in the opinion of the wonks running the York University Student Centre.
Indeed, the question arises: If Genuis was a member of the NDP or if he was an all-out Marxist, would he be treated in such a fashion by leftist student organizations? We highly doubt it, especially given York University’s history of welcoming radicalized speakers on campus.
Regardless, the crux of the matter is that there’s this obscure document called the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, and this charter guarantees the fundamental freedom of thought, belief, opinion, and expression. Apparently, the York University Student Centre feels that its manifesto supersedes the Charter. That’s equal parts sad and laughable.
And seriously, if an elected representative can be censored on campus, what chance does any student have to speak freely?
In fact, universities should be — and used to be — marketplaces of ideas. Now they seem to be gated free speech zones controlled by politicized unions or administrators — or "student centres."
Reality check: Free speech is not a privilege — it’s a right. Even if the speech in question is deemed to be "offensive."
Rebel News paid a visit to York University on Friday. We wanted to see what the kids on campus had to say about this censorious act. Were they offended? Or are they so indoctrinated that they think banning certain opinions and speakers is perfectly fine? (Spoiler alert: The response, tragically, was about fifty-fifty.)
We also brought along our big, beautiful billboard truck to condemn the censorship on campus. Hopefully, we didn’t offend the rank-and-file of the York University Student Centre. Please sign our petition at www.FreeSpeechTruck.com.
Of note, the executive director of the York University Centre, Jason Goulart (He/Him/His), declined our offer to come on camera to justify the cancellation of the Genuis event. But Goulart (He/Him/His) did provide a written explanation to us via email:
“The event in question was not approved to proceed due to the application of our booking policies and event request procedures and was not politically motivated in any way. Our booking policies are applied equitably to all student clubs and external organizations looking to hold events and promotional tabling in our spaces regardless of content or affiliation. We found that this particular booking simply did not satisfy our requirements. The groups and persons looking to book this event are free to re-apply at any time, subject to our approval and that our requirements are satisfied.
“The organizers of this particular event simply did not provide enough detail for us to adequately assess the type of programming, appropriate channels and venue required. The York Federation of Students (YFS) was not involved in any way, the York University Student Centre (YUSC) administers all YUSC facilities.”
So, the cancellation of Garnett Genuis was some sort of paperwork/procedural issue? Are you buying what Goulart (He/Him/His) is selling? And say, whatever happened to “reasonable accommodation”?
David Menzies
Journalist and 'Mission Specialist'
David “The Menzoid” Menzies is the Rebel News "Mission Specialist." The Menzoid is equal parts outrageous and irreverent as he dares to ask the type of questions those in the Media Party would rather not ponder.
COMMENTS
-
Dalyce McCue commented 2026-01-12 21:04:02 -0500Those students should take Charlie Kirk’s advice and get out of the universities. What are they learning besides being indocrinated? I shudder to think that all those students are going to be the next generation of government workers. -
Bruce Atchison commented 2026-01-12 19:22:05 -0500Defund York University! Let them practice their partizanship as a private school without federal funding.
-
Anthony Salotti commented 2026-01-11 07:33:03 -0500Yup , it was because Garnett Genuis was a conservative . -
Melvyn Schobel commented 2026-01-10 23:24:36 -0500Conservatives need to raise issues — they need to get their heads out of the sand and start being a party with some backbone. Poilievre is a wimp, a great public speaker, but lacks the will to set the world on fire. He is afraid to take a stand, as it might go against the false narrative being peddled by the left. He goes with the tide but flounders when the waves get rough. Canada is in deep trouble, and what it needs is a strong leader. Unfortunately, Poilievre is not the answer. It is no surprise that two members of the Conservative Party have defected. One more and we end up with a majority government. Carney knows some members are not happy with Portiere’s leadership and is taking full advantage of the situation. They had a chance to defeat the government with a non-confidence vote, but understood there was little chance of succeeding if an election was called. Happy days are here again!